今天_晴
对
Amusing Ourselves to Death
的书评
发表时间:2011-01-26 11:01:05
这是一本老书了。
排除作者当时的局限(比如对计算机的不屑 or am I talking under the influence of the internet/information age already?)作者的很多观点跟Nicholas Carr的the shallows是非常类似。
也许每个新科技诞生都伴随了怀有Loyal old time thinking 的那些人的痛苦反思?
作者预言的很多现象都已经发生了,人们的attention spam更短了,有了internet,frequent interruption, frequent distraction又重新上升到了前所未有的程度。不过人们也已经习以为常了。
这本书的文字有着那个时代的特点,kinda similarly verbose to "how to read a book", and has a quaint feeling to it. It's not a relaxing read, but it gives one a peculiar sense of enjoyment when reading it with classic music playing (yikes, entertainment again!) with warm fire in the winter time...but I digress.
我想人们不可能抵制科技和时代的进步。当written language 被广泛传播代替口头表达的时候,当时的人们也感叹“记忆”这项能力给损失掉了。但是获得的自然是更加广泛的传播知识,信息,技能等等。
当电报被发明,无意义的新闻被当作新奇的事物传播和消费,人们失去了背景思考和对所听见的事物做出反应的能力。但是我觉得,现在的人们学习新事物,有前所未有的联想能力,从广泛接触里面产生mash up的能力,显然是增加了。不觉得一定是坏事。(再次离题一下,在TED talks 里面TED曾经说过,这个时代video影像能传播到世界的各个角落,带来的好处和产生的效果是在其普及之前非常难想到的。比如他举了一个例子说,地球一个角落的年轻人录制了自己跳舞的 刺激了人们学习和提高的欲望,地球另外一个角落的年轻人看见了,模仿了,并且试图超越之,这样飞快的,大家都在one-up-manship 里面,共同提高飞跃了。比如前阵子看见a 4 yr-old跳舞,居然也有手放在裆部这样的“主流”动作。另外在youtube上还看见俺学校一个学生(应该是韩国后裔)学着韩国某偶像band跳舞的录像,其实真的还满象那么回事的!我自己是喜欢做蛋糕,大约10年之前的书,杂志和照片还都非常有限,会做的人不多。如今只要想学,绝对没有学不会的道理,电视,网络帮助了这些信息技能的传播。在现代化的传播手段真正流行起来之前,谁又能想到这些技术可以这样来用呢?
这点就好像NNT所说的,在新的发明被发明出来之前人们是无法预测未来的。所以人们根本就是无法预测未来的。
我想我并不象这位作者,和nicholas Carr那样悲观。
Yes, we lose some, and we gain some。至于是损失更大还是收获更大,绝对的还是看自己的应用。
比如Carr说的eReader比如kindle offers too many distractions to read a book in its entirety. 但是例子似乎是一个新拿到kindle的人吧?用熟悉了之后我不觉得每个人都会去flip this and that。Actually one advantage Kindle has over the other fancy tech stuff is its simplicity and difficulty in accessing web/games and other distractions.
Before the internet it would be hard to find a book that suits one's taste, and one's "consumption" of books largely depends on what others consume. There a '"mass media" effect.
Nowadays, well the mass is still there yet we are increasingly allow to delve more and more into one's very own niche.
惭愧的说我本人使劲读书时间的时间才不到两年,but I was able to search and find a lot of good books that gave me deeper contemplation as well as enjoyment. 如果愿意,人还是可以,有能力cut out distractions and focus on the "now", the current task at hand, as long as one really wants to.
我想,在科技这个问题上,我持绝对乐观的态度。我不认为TV age and then the later internet age 里面长大的小孩比我们这些老一辈的人要Inferior. Each generation has their own unique features.
Embrace change with grace. Retain what we hold as essential to our being and existence. And enjoy the ride. Seriously.